12 Dec 2022
Many people find it gruesome, disgusting, or repulsive. But when Jörg Heidhues, Stefan Kirchner, and Dirk Sindermann look at insects; the process engineer, sales manager, and head of process technology for renewable raw materials; they see one thing in particular – possibilities. The possibility to produce high-quality protein in an environmentally friendly way. The possibility to integrate secondary streams of food production into a sustainable cycle. And the possibility to secure the world’s protein supply in a climate-neutral way for the long term.
“If you look at the nutritional, economic and environmental facts, it is quickly evident why insects are rich in vitamins and nutrients and have high protein content,” Stefan explains. “They are also cheap to breed and are efficient in terms of resources, as they have a short development cycle, rapid population growth, and high weight gain per day, with high conversion of feed to body weight. Up to 80% of this body weight can be used for nutrition. In comparison to chickens, this figure is 55%, while with cattle, it is 40%.” From an environmental perspective, this means less space required, lower water consumption, and a reduced carbon footprint,” adds Jörg.
- Stefan Kirchner
“In view of our current problem – the ever-growing world population has an ever-increasing demand for protein that we can no longer meet through our conventional protein suppliers like livestock, without causing irreparable damage to the environment and climate so we urgently need sustainable alternatives,” says Stefan. Jörg adds: “Furthermore, insects offer the possibility of a sustainable circular economy. We can use the secondary streams from food production to breed insects.”
Insects are also a sustainable alternative in relation to feed: “Afterall, in nature a chicken also eats insects,” says Dirk. Process engineer Jörg Heidhues shares an example of how a sustainable zero-waste interlinking system might work: “If a customer already has a facility with laying hens, then they can convert a few of the existing barns into an insect facility, build a biogas plant for energy production, and add a fish farm. The result is a closed, self-sustaining cycle, practically without any waste, which will be climate-neutral.”
“Of course, this also leads us to think creatively about what synergies can be created for our existing customers – the dairies, breweries, and oil mills with their various secondary streams,” says Sindermann.
- Dirk Sindermann
“The breeding of insects on a large scale began around 30 years ago. The starting point was mainly universities, which rediscovered insects as a biological means of plant protection and used them in greenhouses – ladybugs, for example, whose favorite food is aphids. However, breeding is quite different from fractionation, in other words making it usable for lipids and protein. This is precisely our area of expertise, so it was almost inevitable that we got involved here.
We take care of everything that needs to be done after the insects have been bred, so that the insect protein is ready for use in the food or feed industry. This includes devitalization of the larvae, crushing and heating, actual separation of the protein in the decanter with subsequent evaporation and drying, as well as polishing of the lipid phase.
However, there are a few challenges to overcome. For example, insect protein tends to oxidize during drying, which in turn affects the stability and taste of the end product. Our process line guarantees highly efficient separation, so a lot less oxidation takes place,” says Kirchner. The evaporator in turn helps to save energy.
“While around 1.3 to 1.8 tons of steam is needed to evaporate one ton of water in a dryer, the vacuum evaporator uses the condensation heat produced as a source of energy. This way around 50% of the water can be removed from the dryer without any additional thermal energy. So, this stage really pays off, not only in terms of current energy costs,” says Stefan Kirchner. “We have been designing and building centrifuges for 130 years and working with all kinds of protein varieties for over 60 years,” explains Dirk Sindermann, “but it’s not just the decades of experience, everybody at GEA is united in using our expertise to find truly tailored solutions for our customers.”
“It’s like planning a kitchen,” Dirk explains. The kitchen needs to fit the customer’s needs – their recipes and their end products. And it fits precisely – the best high-performance, state-of-the-art oven is of no use to them if their main business is making smoothies. This is where we know what needs to happen before, during, and after a process. Therefore, we also rely on wet extraction with centrifugal separation technology for insect protein, because compared to the alternative dry process, this not only has the benefits of the low oxidation rate - previously mentioned but is also more energy-efficient and ensures a higher overall product quality.”
- Jörg Heidhues
Jörg Heidhues continues: “The first thing we do is go to the lab and ask what the best way is to crush this particular insect? Does dwell time and/or pH value have an impact? This is why we support academic work, such as Bachelor’s and Master’s theses. For example, we have found out that the processing of insects is more complex once they have been frozen, and we have learnt how to avoid the browning effect, referring to the rapid browning of the end product due to oxidation – think: sliced apples – by initially devitalizing them. Since we are always pondering the next step at GEA, we are able to come up with concepts for what is yet to come – the extraction of protein isolates with protein values of up to 90%, and with the highest biological availability,” Jörg Heidhues adds.
“And in the form of a neutral powder, with maximum functionality and neutral taste, resource-efficient, climate-neutral, and environmentally efficient – in short, everything you could ask for from a protein,” says Dirk Sindermann.